Class Discussion: 4×15 “Girls (and Boys) on Film” Reaction

Editors’ Note: episode reactions at Deconstructing Glee come from a rotating panel of contributors from all around the globe. Let us know if you’d like to be part of our Secret Society of Superheroes, here.

Glee is a show that loves its pop culture references, but “Girls (and Boys) on Film” has so many shout outs it will  take more than one watch to catch them all.

Screen Shot 2013-03-08 at 5.59.15 PMWill’s love of old movies inspires a dream where Emma didn’t flee (He refers to Dream Emma as “Emma Schuester”). The couple channels Fred Astaire to recreate a scene from Royal Wedding where they dance up the walls and on the ceiling. Will is panicked by this, and wakes from the dream shouting about being up-side-down. Will’s world is currently topsy-turvey, and while both of them being dressed in tuxedos is a part of the movie moment it’s worth noting that someone wanted to get married in the last episode, and it wasn’t anyone in a wedding dress. The color also drains from the screen during the song leaving us in black and white. What does this mean for Emma whose wardrobe is usually bursting with color?

Despite the competition between the boys and girls Blaine brings the club together for a performance of “Shout.” The number travels through the school picking up students as it moves. This isn’t the first time the student body has joined a glee club number, but is there a different vibe in the air? Even with the mention of Animal House the song doesn’t finish with a food fight. This is not the same reaction the club received just a season ago in “The Purple Piano Project.”

Screen Shot 2013-03-08 at 6.00.47 PMThe boys go the traditional route with a mash-up song and two “hyper masculine” movies Risky Business and Top Gun. What did you think of the use of Artie’s chair in regards to the choreography? It was used more like a prop than I think we’ve seen before with the play of spinning the wheel almost like revving a car engine.

The girls don’t mash-up songs, they only use “Diamonds Are A Girl’s Best Friend,” but they’ve got a pop culture mash-up worth paying attention to. The song used comes from the movie Moulin Rouge which involves a quick line from Madonna’s song “Material Girl.” The girl’s dresses are exactly what you see Madonna wearing in her “Material Girl” music video, which is in turn a tribute to Marilyn Monroe in Gentlemen Prefer Blondes who is singing “Diamonds Are A Girl’s Best Friend.” They never outright say it, but they’re also the hyper-feminine counterpoint to the boy’s number.

Meanwhile, the New York crew is actually watching Moulin Rouge, a love story between a writer and a prostitute. Last episode, a lot of us speculated that Brody might be involved in sex work, and this episode has Santana theorizing drug dealer. Usually, movies have women playing sex workers and men playing drug dealers. Considering that both Moulin Rouge and Risky Business are movies that feature prostitution what side are you leaning toward?

Screen Shot 2013-03-08 at 6.04.57 PMKurt also gets a romantic dream sequence, but he’s quickly woken from it. First by Santana, who talks (loudly and in public) about his still very real feelings for Blaine, and later from Adam. Adam asks Kurt to end the fantasy about Blaine, so that he can make a new love story with the flesh and blood boy in front of him. Is Adam’s Kurt’s rebound or does he have a real shot? What does it say that T.V. references only are used in this episode in relation to Adam while the rest of the characters get movies?

Santana is one of the few characters that hasn’t cast herself in a fantasy film. Brody’s famous makeover line is reused on Santana, but she questions it rather than taking it as gospel. She doesn’t talk about New York as though it’s Heaven either, and she’s got a running list of its flaws even while admitting that she likes the city. Is Santana’s ability to see things as they really are a sign of her maturity? Is she playing the game better than Kurt and Rachel?

Screen Shot 2013-03-08 at 6.08.12 PMAnd speaking of casting ourselves in movies. When Marley and Jake recreate Ghost we cut to Marley sitting on the ground watching the scene as though she were watching a movie of her life. She can’t decide whom to cast as her love interest, and we see both Jake and Ryder auditioning for the part. Marley also brings up The Hunger Games and we could write this off as just a reference to another love triangle, but is that the case? The Hunger Games is not primarily a love story, but also one about a young woman surviving impossible tasks while feeling powerless. Would the show have just used Twilight if they wanted us to only focus on romance?

Thoughts? Ideas? Movie moments I missed? What did you think of Artie and Finn looking like long lost Weasley children?

This week’s post written by Poemsingreenink, Secret Society of Superheroes
Age: 29
Location: USA
Primary Glee interests: I like the whole show, but I pay extra attention to the GLBTQ characters.
What else: Be excellent to each other.
Also lives


2 thoughts on “Class Discussion: 4×15 “Girls (and Boys) on Film” Reaction

  1. I don’t know if this is worth pointing out, but “Moulin Rouge”, “Risky Business” and Brody’s arc all show a specific kind of prostitution. They’re all about high-end escorts. This, to me, adds another layer of illusion to the story and you can see this bluntly in “Moulin Rouge.” This notion of courtesan as balancing the line between fantasy and reality, metaphor for both and how those things end up bleeding into each other. The stage of Moulin Rouge was lavish, fantastical and surrounded in expensive electric lighting and audience peopled by wealthy men literally tossing jewels at the performers, especially Satine. While the backstage and home of most of the performers revealed the actual hardship, poverty-stricken and abusive reality of the location it’s set (one of the poorest areas of Paris) and origin of most of the performers. Most were plucked straight from the streets to work in the MR. In “Come What May”, Kurt seems to have been cast in the role of Satine, the one balancing fantasy (lies, denial) and reality. Though despite Satine tried to deny the reality of her love of Christian and ultimately the fact she was very sick & dying (even before Zidler confirmed it to her, she’d have to have known, no matter her denials, something was wrong when the symptoms were never getting better), those realities caught up to her and became overwhelming by the end of the film. Even the threat of death (Christian’s by way of the Duke) and her illness, she faced down and embraced her love for Christian publicly and went peacefully to her death, on the same stage (well, as peacefully as one can dying from tuberculosis). Will Kurt come to the point reality will be inevitable & unavoidable and he embraces it publicly as Satine (on the NYADA stage, perhaps)? Even if it means his and even potentially Blaine’s ‘death(s)’ (or whatever metaphors exist for that in “Glee”)?

  2. @ Sophia: You made me think about relationships as performance. Just as Brody performs the romantic boyfriend Rachel wishes she had (his whole speech when he was late, the Valentine’s decoration of the loft, even his naked support of her nudity-for-the-arts, the high-end sex worker often performs a relationship and emotions that go beyond “just sex” for her clients. In contrast to that, Kurt performs a *lack* of love for Blaine when he insists they are “just friends,” just as Satine performs the lack of love for Christian in an attempt to save his life. I’m not sure where I’m going with this observation, but I find the compare-and-contrast parallels between the two couples interesting as always.

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s